Леонид Вишняцкий - Вооруженное насилие в палеолите

• Название: Вооруженное насилие в палеолите
• Автор: Леонид Вишняцкий
• Издательство: Stratum plus.
• Жанр: История

Статья посвящена вопросу о существовании и интенсивности вооруженного насилия на разных стадиях палеолита. В первых двух разделах даны обзор и анализ палеоантропологических и изобразительных данных, имеющих отношение к этой теме. В третьем разделе рассматривается проблема оценки изменений в интенсивности вооруженного насилия по ископаемым материалам. Собраны и представлены (табл. 1 и 2) все доступные сведения о находках на памятниках палеолита и мезолита костей людей и животных с застрявшими в них фрагментами каменных или костяных наконечников. Показано, что все находки такого рода возрастом старше 15 тыс. лет — это кости животных (10 костей 10 особей с 9 памятников). Напротив, после 15 тыс. лет соотношение резко меняется, и число находок человеческих костей с вонзившимися в них обломками оружия (29 костей 27 индивидов с 17 памятников) почти сравнивается с числом аналогичных находок костей животных. Учитывая, что количество раскопанных фаунистических остатков на несколько порядков превышает количество антропологических находок, такое равенство может свидетельствовать о важных изменениях в динамике вооруженного насилия (и жизни общества в целом) в конце палеолита.

---

Зенин и др. 2006: Зенин В. И., Лещинский С. В., Золотарев К. В., Грутес П. М., Надо М.-Х. 2006. Геоархеология и особенности материальной культуры палеолитического местонахождения Луговское. Археология, этнография и антропология Евразии 1, 41–53.

Нужний Д. Ю. 2008. Розвиток микролтичног техники в кам’яному вщ: удосконаления зброг передних мисливцв. Кигв: КНТ.

Праслов Н. Д. 1995. Мамонт в жизни палеолитического человека. Цитология 37, 634–635.

Телепн Д. Я. 1961. Васил1вський третш некрополь в Надпоргжжг Археологiя 13, 3—19.

Шнирельман В. А. 1994. У истоков войны и мира. В: Война и мир в ранней истории человечества. Т. 1. Москва: Институт этнологии и антропологии РАН, 9—176.

Anderson J. E. Late Paleolithic skeletal remains from Nubia. In: F. Wendorf (ed.). The Prehistory of Nubia. Dallas: Fort Burgwin Research Center & Southern Methodist University Press, 996—1040.

Arias Cabal et al. 2005: Arias Cabal P., Ontanon Peredo R., Alvarez Fernandez E., Aparicio M. T., Chauvin A., Clemente Conte I., Cueto Rapado M., Gonzalez Urquijo J. E., Ibanez Estevez J. J., Tapia Sagarna J., Teira Mayolini L. C. 2005. La estructura Magdale- niense de La Garma A. Aproximacion a la organization espacial de un habitat paleolltico. En: Ferreira Bicho N. (ed.). O Paleolitico. Actas do IV Congresso de arqueologia peninsular. Faro: Universidade do Algarve, 123–141.

Bachechi et al. 1997: Bachechi L., Fabbri P.-F., Mallegni F. 1997. An arrow-caused lesion in a Late Upper Palaeolithic human pelvis. CAn 38, 135–140.

Bahn P. G., Vertut J. 1988. Images of the Ice Age. New York: Facts on File.

Balout L. 1958. Algerie prehistorique. Paris: A. M. G.

Bar-Yosef O. 2010. Warfare in Levantine Early Neolithic. A hypothesis to be considered. Neo-Lithics (1), 6—10.

Bartosiewicz L., Gal E. 2008. Symptoms of aggression on animal bones from archaeological sites. Animal welfare, etologia es tartastechnologia 4, 3—25.

Bello et al. 2011: Bello S. M., Parfitt S.A., Stringer C. B.

2011. Earliest directly-dated human skull-cups. PLoS ONE 6 (2): e17026. doi:10.1371/journal. pone.0017026

Bocquentin F., Bar-Yosef O. 2004. Early Natufian remains: evidence for physical conflict from Mt. Carmel, Israel. JHE 47, 19–23.

Begoubn et al. 1922: Begoubn H., Cugulieres, Miquel H. 1922. Vertebre humaine traversee par une lame en quartzite. Revue anthropologique 32, 230—2.

Behrens H. W. 1978. Der Kampf in der Steinzeit (Ein Dis- kussionsbeitrag vom Aspekt des Prahistorikers. Mitteilungen der Anthropologischen Gesellschaft in Wien 108, 1–7.

Belcastro et al. 2010: Belcastro M. G., Condemi S., Mari- otti V. 2010. Funerary practices of the Iberomauru- sian population of Taforalt (Tafoughalt, Morocco, 11–12,000 BP): the case of Grave XII. JHE 58, 522–532.

Beltran A. 1982. RockArt of the Spanish Levant. The Imprint of Man. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Bettinger R. L. 2013. Effects of the bow on social organization in Western North America. Evolutionary Anthropology 22, 118–123.

Boaz N. T., Ciochon R. L. 2004. Headstrong hominids. Natural History 113 (1), 28–34.

Boaz N. T., Ciochon R. L. 2004а. Dragon Bone Hill: An Ice- Age Saga of Homo erectus. New York: Oxford University Press.

Bobda et al. 1999: Bobda E., Geneste J. M., Griggo C., Mer- cier N., Muhesen S., Reyss J. L., Taha A., Valladas H. 1999. A Levallois point embedded in the vertebra of a wild ass (Equus africanus): hafting, projectiles and Mousterian hunting weapons. Antiquity 73, 394–402.

Boesch C. 2009. The Real Chimpanzee. Sex Strategies in the Forest. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Bokonyi S. 1984. Animal Husbandry and Hunting in Tac-Gorsium. The Vertebrate Fauna of a Roman Town. Budapest: Akademiai Kiado.

Boroneant V., Nicolaescu-Plop§or D. 1990. Lesions trauma- tiques violentes datant de l'Epipaleolithique tardif du sud-ouest de la Roumanie. Anthropologie 28, 55–65.

Bratlund B. 1996. Hunting strategies in the Late Glacial on Northern Europe: A survey of the faunal evidence. Journal of World Prehistory 10, 1—48.

Brennan M. U. 1991. Health and Disease in the Middle and Upper Paleolithic of Southwestern France: A Bioarcheological Study. Unpublished Ph. D. dissertation. New York University.

Buzhilova A. P. 2005. The environment and health condition of the Upper Palaeolithic Sunghir people of Russia. Journal of Physiological Anthropology and Applied Human Science 24, 413–418.

Caspari R. 1997. Evidence of pathology on the frontal bone from Gongwangling. AJPA 102, 565–568.

Christensen J. 2004. Warfare in the European Neolithic. Acta Archaeologica 75, 129–156.

Churchill et al. 2009: Churchill S. E., Franciscus R. G., McKean-Peraza H.A., Daniel J.A., Warren B. R. 2009. Shanidar 3 Neandertal rib puncture wound and Paleolithic weaponry. JHE 57, 163–178.

Clottes J., Courtin J. 1994. La Grotte Cosquer. Paris: Editions du Seuil.

Cordier G. 1990. Blessures prehistoriques animales et hu- maines avec armes ou projectiles conserves. Bulletin de la Societe prehistorique franqaise 87, 462–482.

Dams L. 1984. Les peintures rupestres du Levant espagnol. Paris: Picard.

Defleur et al. 1999: Defleur A., White T., Valensi P., Sli- mak L., Cregur-Bonnoure E. 1999. Neanderthal cannibalism at Moula-Guercy, Ardeche, France. Science 286, 128–131.

Delluc B., Delluc G. 1971. La grotte ornee de Sous-Grand- Lac (Dordogne). Gallia prehistoire 14, 245–252.

Estabrook V. H. 2009. Sampling biases and new ways of addressing the significance of trauma in Neandertals. Unpublished Ph. D. dissertation. The University of Michigan.

Estabrook W. H., Frayer D. W. 2013. Trauma in the Krapina Neandertals: Violence in the Middle Paleolithic? In: C. Knusel, M. Smith (eds.). The Routledge Handbook of the Bioarchaeology of Human Conflict. London: Routledge, 67–89.

Ferguson R. B. 2013. Pinkers's List. Exaggerating prehistoric war morality. In: D. P. Fry (ed.). War, Peace, and Human Nature: The Convergence of Evolutionary and Cultural Views. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 112—131

Formicola V. 2007. From the Sunghir children to the Romito dwarf. Aspects of the Upper Paleolithic funerary landscape. CAn 48, 446–453.

Franciscus R. G., Holliday T. W. 2013. Crossroads of the Old World: Late hominin evolution in Western Asia. In: Smith F. H., Ahern J. C. M. (eds.). The Origins of Modern Humans: Biology Reconsidered. Hoboken: Wiley, 45–88.

Guilaine J., Zammit J. 2005. The Origins of War. Violence in Prehistory. Malden: Blackwell.

Guthrie R. D. 2005. The Nature of Paleolithic Art. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.

Henry-Gambier D. 2005. Evolution des pratiques funeraires en Italie au Paleolithique superieur. In: Vialou D., Renault-Mikosky J., Pathou-Mathis M. (eds.). Com- portements des hommes du Paleolithique moyen et superieur en Europe: territoires et milieux. Liege: ERAUL 111, 213—29.

Henry-Gambier D. 2008. Comportement de populations d'Europe au Gravettien: pratiques funeraires et interpretations. Paleo 20, 165–204.

Hernandez Perez et al. 1995: Hernandez Perez M. S., Mar- set P. F. I., Ferrer E. C. 1995. Arte rupestre en Alicante. Alicante: Fundacion Banco Exterior.

Jackes M. K. 2004. Osteological evidence for Mesolithic and Neolithic violence: Problems of interpretation. In: Roksandic M. (ed.). Violent Interactions in the Mesolithic: Evidence and Meaning. BAR IS 1237. Oxford: Archaeopress, 23–39.

Judd M. 2004. News from the British Museum. British Association for Biological Anthropology and Osteoar- chaeology Annual Review 5, 5.

Klaatsch H. 1920. Der Werdegang der Menschheit und die Entstehung der Kultur. Berlin: Deutsches Verlags- haus Bong und Co.

Klima B. 1988. A triple burial from the Upper Paleolithic of Dolni Vestonice, Czechoslovakia. JHE 16, 831–835.

Koslowski S. K., Sachse-Koslowska E. 1993. Maszycka Cave: a Magdalenian site in Southern Poland. Jahrbuch der Romisch-Germanischen Zentralmuse- ums 40, 115–205.

LeBlanc S. 2010. Early Neolithic warfare in the Near East and its broader implications. Neo-Lithics (1), 40–49.

Leroi-Gourhan A. 1968. The art of prehistoric man in Western Europe. London: Thames & Hudson.

Letourneux C., Petillon J.-M. 2008. Hunting lesions caused by osseous projectile points: experimental results and archaeological implications. JAS 35, 2849–2862.

Lopez-Montalvo E. 2011. Violence et mort dans Part rupes- tre du Levant: groupes humains et territoire. Dans: Baray L., Honegger M., Dias-Meirinho M. H. (dir.). L’armement et l’image du guerrier dans les socie- tes anciennes: de l’objet a la tombe. Dijon: Editions universitaires de Dijon, 19–42.

Martin H. 1907. Recherches sur revolution du Mousterien dans le gisement de la Quina. Tome 1. Paris: Schleicher.

Martin H. 1934. Pathologie osseuse prehistorique. Bles- sure par arme de jet sur une vertebre de renne. Compte-rendu de la 58e session de l’Association franqaise pour l’avancement des sciences. Rabat, 183–184.

McCown T. D., Keith A. 1939. The Stone Age of Mount Carmel. Vol. 2. The Fossil Human Remains from the Levalloiso-Mousterian. Oxford: Clarendon.

Mezzena F. 1976. Nuova interpretazione delle incisioni pa- rietali paleolitiche della Grotta Addaura a Palermo. Rivista di scienze preistoriche 31, 61–85.

Monk S. J. 1997. Conflict and competition in Spanish prehistory: the role of warfare in societal development from the late fourth to third millennium BC. Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology 10 (1), 3—32.

Morel P. 1998. La grotte du Bichon (La Chaux-de-Fonds, canton de Neuchatel, Suisse). Dans: Les derniers chasseurs-cueilleurs du massif jurassien et de ses marges. Lons-le-Saunier: Centre jurassien du patri- moine, 88–93.

Munzel S. C., Conard N. J. 2004. Cave bear hunting in the Hohle Fels, a cave site in the Ach Valley, Swabian Jura. Revue de Paleobiologie 23 (2): x-xx.

Napierala et al. 2010: Napierala H., Honeisen M., Traut- mann M. 2010. «Stirb an einem anderen Tag» — Schussverletzung eines Rentiers vom Magdale- nienfundplatz Kesslerloch bei Thayngen (Kt. Schaffhausen). Archaologisches Korrespondenz- blatt 40, 457–466.

Nash J. 2005. Assessing rank and warfare-strategy in prehistoric hunter-gatherer society: a study of representational warrior figures in rock-art from the Spanish Levant, southeastern Spain. In: Pearson M. P., Thorpe I. J. N. (eds.). Warfare, Violence and Slavery in Prehistory. Proceedings of a Prehistoric Society Conference at Sheffield University. (BAR IS 1374). Oxford: Archaeopress, 75–87.

Nikolskiy P., Pitulko V. 2013. Evidence from the Yana Palaeolithic site, Arctic Siberia, yields clues to the riddle of mammoth hunting. JAS 40, 4189–4197.

Noe-Nygaard N. 1974. Mesolithic hunting in Denmark illustrated by bone injuries caused by human weapons. JAS 1, 217–248.

Noe-Nygaard et al. 2007: Noe-Nygaard N., Milan J., Hede M. U., Holm J. 2007. A reindeer track from a drill core, and lake basin development of the Late Glacial Lille Slotseng kettle-hole basin, South-East Jylland, Denmark. Bulletin of the Geological Society of Denmark 55, 85–95.

Orschiedt J. 2008. Der Fall Krapina — neue Ergebnisse zur Frage van Kannibalismus beim Neandertaler. Quarter 55, 63–81.

Petillon J.-M., Letourneax C. 2003. Au retour de la chasse… Observations experimentales concernant les impacts sur le gibier, la recuperation et la maintenance des projectiles dans le Magdalenien superieur d'Isturitz (Pyrenees-Atlantiques). Prehistoire Anthropologie

Mediterraneennes 12, 173–188.

Pettitt P. 2011. The Palaeolithic Origins of Human Burial. London; New York: Routledge.

Robb J. 2007. The Early Mediterranean Village. Agency, Material Culture, and Social Change in Neolithic Italy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Robbins L. H., Lynch B. M. 1978. New evidence on the use of microliths from the Lake Turkana Basin, East Africa. CAn 19, 619–620.

Roksandic M. 2004. Contextualizing the evidence of violent death in the Mesolithic: burials associated with victims of violence in the Iron Gates Gorge. In: Roksan- dic M. (ed.). Evidence and Meaning of Violent Interactions in Mesolithic Europe. (BAR IS 1237). Oxford: Archaeopress, 53–74.

Roksandic M. 2006. Violence in the Mesolithic. Documenta Praehistorica 33, 165–182.

Roksandic et al. 2006: Roksandic M., Djuric M., Ra- kocevic Z., Seguin K. 2006. Interpersonal violence at Lepenski Vir Mesolithic/Neolithic complex of the Iron Gates Gorge (Serbia-Romania). AJPA 129, 339–348.

Roper M. K. 1969. A survey of the evidence for intrahuman killing in the Pleistocene. CAn 10, 427—59.

Rosas et al. 2006: Rosas A., Martinez-Maza C., Bas- tir M., Garcia-Tabernero A., Lalueza-Fox C., Hu- guet R., Ortiz J. E., Julia R., Soler V., Torres T. de, Martinez E., Canaveras J. C., Sanchez-Moral S., Cuezva S., Lario J., Santamaria D., Rasilla M. de la, Fortea J. 2006. Paleobiology and comparative morphology of a late Neandertal sample from El Sidron, Asturias, Spain. PNAS 103, 19266—19271.

Ruiz et al. 2006: Ruiz J. F., Mas M., Hernanz A., Rowe M. W., Steelman K. L., Gavira J. M. 2006. First radiocarbon dating of oxalate crusts over Spanish prehistoric rock art. International Newsletter on Rock Art 46, 1–5.

Schulting R. J., Fibiger L. (eds.). 2012. Sticks, Stones, and Broken Bones. Neolithic Violence in a European Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Shang H., Trinkaus E. 2008. An ectocranial lesion on the Middle Pleistocene human cranium from Hulu Cave, Nanjing, China. AJPA 135, 431–437.

Sharma G. R. 1973. Mesolithic lake cultures in the Gan- ga valley, India. PPS 39, 129–146.

Smith et al. 2007: Smith M. J., Brickley M. B., Leach S. L. Experimental evidence for lithic projectile injuries: improving identification of an under-recognised phenomenon. JAS 34, 540–543.

Stock et al. 2005: Stock J. T., Pfeiffer S. K., Chazan M., Ja- netsky J. 2005. F-81 skeleton from Wadi Mataha, Jordan, and its bearing on human variability in the Epipaleolithic of the Levant. AJPA 128, 453–465.

Tagon P., Chippindale C. 1994. Australia's ancient warriors: changing depictions of fighting in the rock art of Arnhem Land, N. T. Cambridge Archaeological Journal 4, 211–248.

Taylor T. 2002. The Buried Soul: How Humanity Invented Death. Boston, MA: Beacon Press.

Tillier A.-M. 1999. Les enfants Mousteriens de Qafzeh: Interpretation phylogenetique et paleoauxologique. Paris: CNRS.